By John Hood
RALEIGH — As we mourn the deaths and grapple with the destruction inflicted on our state by Hurricane Helene, I submit that the storm has brought out much that is good about North Carolina — and much that is vile about social media.
I’ll start with the positive. Residents of the mountain counties most affected by Helene have fought heroically for their lives, their families, and their neighbors, often against long odds and terrifying threats. They haven’t fought alone. Others from across North Carolina and beyond flocked in to help.
We’ve only just begun to collect their stories of prudent planning, daring rescues, and dogged determination. These tales feature the likes of Hendersonville’s James White, who led more than a dozen neighbors sheltering in his home to safety with ropes and lifejackets, as well as Eddie Hunnell, recently moved to North Carolina from Colorado, who leapt into the swollen New River to save a stranger, Lesley Worth, separated from her husband by the raging stream.
At larger scale, hundreds of churches, charities, companies, and volunteer networks sprang to the assistance of their fellow Carolinians. So did law enforcement, fire and rescue teams, and emergency-response personnel from counties, municipalities, state agencies, and other public authorities.
On the ground, we’ve seen a great deal of cooperation across jurisdictional and political boundaries. Agriculture Commissioner Steve Troxler, for example, sent North Carolina Forest Service staffers familiar with the rugged terrain to guide National Guard units into position. On October 7, Democratic and Republican appointees on the State Board of Elections voted unanimously to empower local boards in 13 hard-hit counties to modify the locations and hours of early-voting sites and other election procedures — but only by bipartisan votes of those boards, a prudent constraint to reassure a jittery public.
Democratic mayors have worked closely with Republican county commissioners to coordinate relief. Gov. Roy Cooper, U.S. Sens. Thom Tillis and Ted Budd, lawmakers from both parties — all have pitched in to comfort victims, survey damage, coordinate responses, and convey timely, accurate information to the public.
That’s not to say there haven’t been miscues and disagreements. Tillis and Budd questioned the pace at which military personnel from Fort Liberty and other bases were deployed into the devastated counties after the storm. Others have criticized the adequacy of response by the Federal Emergency Management Agency.
While it will take some time to sort out all the claims and counterclaims, it’s not too early to label these issues as legitimate topics for debate.
Unfortunately, much of the “debate” unfolding on social media over the past week has been anything but legitimate. Whether spreading wacky conspiracy theories about lithium mines and weather control or uttering grotesque slanders about Kamala Harris and Joe Biden intentionally “letting” Republican voters “drown,” a host of very-online, supposedly conservative provocateurs and hacks have made a bad situation immeasurably worse.
Here’s what a real conservative leader, state Sen. Kevin Corbin, had to say. “PLEASE help stop this junk,” wrote Corbin, who represents North Carolina’s eight westernmost counties. “It is just a distraction to people trying to do their job.”
“Folks, this is a catastrophic event of which this country has never known. It is the largest crisis event in the history of N.C. The state is working non-stop. DOT has deployed workers from all over the state. Duke [Energy] has 10,000 workers on this. FEMA is here. The National Guard is here in large numbers.”
Some incendiary memes are likely the product of misunderstandings, such as emergency officials redirecting volunteers away from dangerous roadways or relief agencies refusing certain donated items they aren’t equipped to store or distribute. Others may well be the result of bad calls made in good faith, in stressful conditions, by officials with incomplete information or inadequate training.
Can policymakers properly second-guess such decisions after the fact? Of course! That time will come. Right now, our immediate challenges remain rescue and relief — challenges our fellow North Carolinians have met with magnificent resilience.
John Hood is a John Locke Foundation board member. His latest books, Mountain Folk and Forest Folk, combine epic fantasy with early American history (FolkloreCycle.com).
The 42% will not accept that this wasn’t a geo-engineered attack on them. You call them memes John, Maga calls it truth. Seems like you need to speak louder to your base.
I really think it is time to implement a mandatory civics or political science class – whatever it may be that will curb the tide of the uneducated voters who have come out from under the rocks in the past decade. Conspiracy theory quacks have taken over both voters and members of local, state and federal political offices holders.
I have friends who live all over Europe and the UK – some moved from the US for work related reasons, some retired to other countries and some were born over there – and the US friends are from both parties – but not the new maga party as it has become. Our government officials and some of our voters have been called into question for their sanity by so many other countries.
Also I have friends that live in another country and how they do their voting is really something I wish we would implement: no campaigning except for 6 weeks prior to the election, the candidates are given the same amount of money to spend and after the election – it’s over. No continuing to campaign for the next election etc. Also the tv stations, newscasters, journalists and radio hosts etc., have integrity laws – they cannot knowingly lie. They don’t give opinions – just facts. For instance – when reporting a crime or a train wreck (to name two random events) – they state what is actually known and verified when reporting. Politicians are also bound by the integrity law when they are campaigning. To paraphrase from the dude on Dragnet – just the facts.