Attorney General Opposes Railroad Company Merger

RALEIGH — Attorney General Jeff Jackson is urging the federal government to block a proposed merger between Union Pacific Railroad Company and Norfolk Southern Railway Company, arguing that it would reduce competition and could lead to higher grocery costs and hurt North Carolina farmers.

North Carolina has more than 3,000 miles of freight rail, and the state’s railroads carry large amounts of corn and soybean meal for poultry feed, crushed stone, scrap steel, fertilizer, and many other goods, according to The Association of American Railroads. Norfolk Southern operates more than 1,000 of those miles, making it the largest freight rail network in the state, and it is one of two Class I railroads in North Carolina.

“We know what happens when companies engage in anticompetitive behavior: Costs go up and families pay more,” said Attorney General Jeff Jackson. “Many North Carolinians are already struggling to afford groceries, and letting these companies merge would make it worse. That’s why we’re asking the federal government to make sure that can’t happen.”

Attorney General Jackson and a coalition of 20 other attorneys general filed a comment letter opposing the merger with the Surface Transportation Board (STB), the federal agency that regulates the freight rail industry. The STB has higher competition standards for major mergers of Class I railroads, requiring that they demonstrate that the benefits outweigh the harms to competition. The attorneys general are urging the STB to apply that standard to this proposal and reject the companies’ application to combine.

The merger would reduce competition in the industry, increase the companies’ power to set prices, harm shippers who are dependent on the rail industry, create safety and service risks, create labor concerns, and encourage additional consolidation within the industry.

The letter pointed to comments reportedly made by Union Pacific CEO Jim Vena at the annual Southwest Association of Rail Shippers meeting. Vena allegedly threatened to retaliate against customers who oppose the deal by increasing their rates.

Additionally, the merger would leave shippers of agricultural goods with less bargaining power because farmers would be more dependent on fewer railroads at a time when they already have little power to walk away from high costs or poor service. The merger would weaken any remaining leverage by eliminating route and interchange options that keep prices down. This could mean higher costs being passed on to families at grocery stores.

Attorney General Jackson is joined in sending the letter by the attorneys general of Arizona, Colorado, District of Columbia, Florida, Illinois, Kansas, Maryland, Michigan, Minnesota, Nevada, New Jersey, New Mexico, New York, North Dakota, Oregon, Pennsylvania, South Dakota, Virginia, Washington, and Wisconsin.


Discover more from JoCo Report

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply