What If Thom Tillis Had Run?

By John Hood

RALEIGH — All the North Carolina Democrats I know accept not only the impressiveness but also the improbability of their party’s superlative performance in the 2026 midterms. By contrast, quite a few Republicans I know remain in denial about the extent to which voters turned against their party and its leader, Donald Trump.

Some disenchanted voters with GOP leanings stayed home. Others swung Democratic. You don’t get the worst midterm cycle for Republicans in half a century without both dynamics.

I could hurl gobs of statistics, precedents, and quotes from political consultants at you to support my claim. But I don’t need to, and you’ve probably read your fill of statistic-heavy punditry. Instead, I will underline only a single result from 2026: the GOP’s nominee for U.S. Senate, Michael Whatley, received 39% of the vote. Two years earlier, the party’s nominee for governor, Mark Robinson, got 40% of the vote.

Yes, that Mark Robinson. The unlikable, policy-ignorant, porn-obsessed, self-described “black Nazi” who lost to Josh Stein in a 15-point electoral landslide. He still outperformed Whatley who, whatever his faults as a candidate, was neither a crank nor a kook and yet lost to Roy Cooper in a 20-point electoral earthquake.

As was evident across the country, the central character of the 2026 midterms wasn’t on the ballot. In 2024, voters returned Donald Trump to power largely as a rejection of what they saw as a decrepit Joe Biden, his hapless vice president Kamala Harris, and four years of policy mistakes by Democrats in Washington. Two years later, many of these voters picked Democrats (or stayed home) largely as a rejection of what they saw as a corrupt Trump, the hapless band of Republicans enabling his misrule, and two years of policy mistakes by Republicans in Washington.

Among the many counterfactuals worth exploring, one has the clearest relevance to North Carolina: what if President Trump had resisted his narcissistic tendencies and authoritarian impulses to allow or even support the nomination of traditional, electorally experienced GOP candidates in potential battlegrounds? What if the party’s Senate nominees had been the likes of John Cornyn in Texas, Brian Kemp in Georgia, and Ralph Norman in South Carolina?

And what if, here in North Carolina, Trump and his most-devout followers had tolerated Thom Tillis’s independent streak rather than chasing the two-term senator out of office?

Given the height of the blue tsunami — powered by opposition to the president’s policies, behavior, and seeming indifference to the public’s affordability concerns — it is certainly possible that Democrats would still have won most of these races (but not South Carolina). Nevertheless, it strikes me as highly implausible that a GOP ticket in Texas headed by Cornyn would have lost every statewide office on the ballot as well as the Texas House, or that a GOP ticket in Georgia headed by Kemp would suffered such devastating reverses of their own, or that in our state Democrats would have achieved an 11-3 congressional delegation and near-supermajority in the North Carolina House had Tillis been at the top of the ticket and lost a spirited race against a Democratic opponent who’d previously won six statewide elections.

What doomed down-ballot Republicans in North Carolina’s 2026 midterms to disaster wasn’t just Roy Cooper’s political strengths and fundraising advantages, or Trump’s unpopularity, or a series of smart tactical decisions by Democratic operatives. Each played a role, sure, and would have produced electoral disappointment for the GOP. What turned disappointment into a debacle was the complete collapse of the Whatley campaign during the final weeks of the cycle. The national money left. State money never materialized. Neither did an adequate turnout operation. The energy fizzled.

Down-ballot candidates tried to overcome these disadvantages with their own canvassing, mailers, and ads. Some beat the spread, eking out narrow wins to preserve a Republican majority in the state senate, for example. But even if Thom Tillis had run and lost, the spread wouldn’t have been so hard to beat.

John Hood is a John Locke Foundation board member. His books Mountain Folk, Forest Folk, and Water Folk combine epic fantasy with American history (FolkloreCycle.com).


Discover more from JoCo Report

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

One comment

  1. I believe it’s safe to say that history has proven many times that the longer a tyrant or traitor remains at the head of the government, the weaker the successors become. Never in my 47 years of voting have I seen a weaker group of candidates than the GOP managed to put forward in 2026. As a lifelong Democrat, I don’t see that as a win necessarily. The country has always been stronger and safer when both parties have strong leadership and share in decision making but this latest group of feckless Trumpian loyalists had nowhere to go but down.

Leave a Reply